In 2024, both email marketing and social media marketing are crucial for business success.
Email Marketing is still a powerhouse with billions of users worldwide. It offers a cost-effective direct and personalized communication channel with your audience. In 2022, there were an estimated 333 billion e-mails sent and received daily around the world.
With billions of people spending hours each day on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter, social media offers unmatched reach and engagement. With an average user spending about 2.5 hrs on social media every day, it’s perfect for building your brand and connecting with your audience in real-time.
Which channel is more effective?
Currently, email marketing gives an impressive average return on investment (ROI), earning $36 for every dollar spent on average.
On the other hand, because social media marketing is primarily organic, calculating ROI can be difficult. According to experts, the return on investment for paid social media marketing is $2.80 for every dollar spent.
According to Hubspot's social media trends report 2023, here's the ROI that each social media platform provides:
| Platform | Average ROI |
|---|---|
| 25% | |
| 23% | |
| YouTube | 14% |
| TikTok | 12% |
| 11% | |
| 6% |
Which channel should you choose?
While using both simultaneously is the most ideal solution, sometimes you have to choose due to resource constraints. To help you make an informed decision, we've outlined the pros and cons of each channel:
Email marketing
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Direct and personalized communication | Risk of emails being marked as spam |
| High ROI potential | Requires a well-maintained and segmented email list |
| Effective for nurturing leads through the sales funnel | Design and coding skills needed for visually appealing emails |
| Easily measurable metrics | Possibility of email fatigue among subscribers |
| Cost-effective compared to other marketing channels | Can be less effective in reaching younger demographics |
Social media marketing
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Broad reach to diverse demographics | Organic reach can be limited due to platform algorithms |
| Real-time engagement and interaction | Requires community management |
| Visual and interactive content opportunities | Dependent on platform changes and trends |
| Builds brand awareness and community | Potential for negative feedback or public relations issues |
| Facilitates viral content sharing | Paid advertising may be necessary to reach the target audience |
How to choose the right marketing channel for your business
The pros and cons listed above will help you decide between the two. But if you're still unclear, ask yourself these 8 important questions.
1. Where would your target audience respond?
Understanding where your audience is the most vital factor in choosing between these channels. Younger demographics, such as Gen Z and millennials, are often more active on social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok. They engage with visual content and connect with brands in a more casual setting. On the other hand, older demographics and professionals might prefer email for its direct and formal communication style.
Let’s take a look at which channel you should choose depending on the different aspects of your target audience.
| Factors to consider | Email marketing | Social media marketing |
|---|---|---|
| Demographics | Professionals, mature age groups | Younger generation (e.g., Gen Z, millennials) |
| Content consumption habits | Detailed, informative content | Quick, visual content (images, videos, stories) |
| Engagement levels | Direct communication, personalized engagement | Interactive engagement (likes, shares, comments) |
| Location | Global reach with tailored regional content | Local or region-specific campaigns |
| Industry | B2B industries, professional services | B2C industries, lifestyle brands |
2. What kind of content format suits your message the best?
Social media thrives on quick, visual content that demands frequent updates to maintain visibility and engagement. Platforms like Instagram and Facebook are ideal for businesses looking to interact with their audience through visuals and real-time interaction. They are ideal for, say a restaurant using Instagram Stories for daily specials and behind-the-scenes videos on on their Facebook page.
In contrast, email marketing offers a more personalized approach with in-depth content that can be automated for efficiency. It is suitable for businesses like online course providers sending weekly newsletters with educational articles, video tutorials, and webinar announcements.
That said, interactive emails are better than regular ones because they let you do more right in your inbox. You can take polls, fill out surveys, or even join quizzes—all without leaving the email. It’s like having a mini-website experience without clicking away. This makes emails more engaging and increases how much people interact with them.
Email service providers like Mailmodo let you create interactive emails in minutes with their no-code drag-and-drop email editor. You can even choose from their tried-and-tested email template library to get ideas for your next email campaign.
You can read more about creating interactive emails in our related guide below.
Let’s take a look at which channel you should choose depending on the different aspects of your content format.
| Factors to consider | Email marketing | Social media marketing |
|---|---|---|
| Content type | Text-based newsletters, detailed articles | Visual content (images, videos), stories (depending on platform: Instagram, TikTok) |
| Brand voice | Professional tone, detailed explanations suited for longer-form content | Casual, engaging, conversational suited for shorter, more immediate interactions |
| Production resources | Requires writing and editing skills; minimal graphic design and video resources | Requires visual content creation (graphic design, video editing), potentially higher production costs |
| Time sensitivity | Scheduled campaigns, drip sequences with less urgent content | Real-time updates, trending topics requiring immediate responses |
3. What is your budget?
Budget plays a crucial role in deciding between email and social media marketing. Email campaigns are generally more cost-effective. They require minimal investment beyond email service provider (ESP) fees, domain names and content creation. This makes them suitable for startups or small businesses.
In contrast, social media marketing often demands a larger allocation for content creation, advertising, and influencer partnerships. This makes it more suitable for businesses with a higher marketing budget seeking to enhance brand visibility and expand their audience reach.
That said, there are exceptions. Rocks Box is known as 'The Sephora of Jewelry,' all because of their killer Instagram campaigns. Based in San Francisco, they're loved for their delicate, high-quality jewellery. With 220k loyal followers, their Instagram page embodies luxury and lifestyle, despite having a tight budget.
They smartly use influencer partnerships to boost engagement without hefty ad spending. Influencers showcase their products, tagging Rocks Box and spreading the word organically.
4. What is your immediate marketing goal?
Your immediate marketing goal dictates whether email marketing or social media marketing is more appropriate. Social media excels in enhancing brand visibility and awareness through viral content and community interaction.
Confluent, a top data streaming platform, shines on LinkedIn with 500,000+ followers. They use tech-focused content like interviews with industry leaders from companies like Wealthsimple to engage and educate their audience effectively. This strategy helps them build trust and attract enterprise customers looking for innovative solutions.
Conversely, email marketing focuses on nurturing customer relationships and driving engagement.
Let’s take a look at which channel you should choose depending on your marketing goal.
| Factors to consider | Email marketing | Social media marketing |
|---|---|---|
| Audience intent | Direct interaction for immediate conversion | Brand exposure over time leading to conversion |
| Lead nurturing capability | Effective for personalized, drip campaign nurturing | Facilitates ongoing engagement and community building |
| Market saturation | Less saturated, more opportunity for differentiation | Highly competitive, potential for virality |
| Content virality potential | Lower virality potential, focused on targeted audience | Higher potential for content to reach broader audience |
| Purchase cycle | Effective for converting leads in decision stages | Raises awareness and nurtures leads in discovery stages |
| Campaign objectives | Ideal for lead generation, targeted promotions | Effective for brand awareness, product launches |
You can read more about email analytics in our related guide below.
5. Is flexibility in engagement timing important to you?
Social media’s real-time nature allows for immediate interaction and responsiveness to trends and events. You can make quick adjustments in content and strategy to capitalize on current affairs and maximize visibility. For example, a retail brand can capitalize on trending hashtags on Twitter to engage with its audience and boost visibility.
In contrast, email marketing’s scheduled delivery enables precise timing for optimal open rates and engagement, albeit with less real-time adaptability. Choosing between the two depends on your need for agility versus strategic planning.
6. Which metrics do you need to measure?
Both email and social media marketing rely on metrics for continuous improvement. Key metrics include open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and engagement metrics like likes, shares, and comments.
These insights inform adjustments to content strategy, audience targeting, and campaign optimization. Regular analysis and refinement based on these metrics are crucial for sustained marketing success.
The advantage of email marketing is that you can compare campaign metrics against industry standards. While it’s difficult to find performance benchmarks for social media marketing.
7. How does it integrate with your other marketing strategies?
Integrating email and social media marketing with other strategies enhances overall marketing effectiveness. Email marketing integrates seamlessly with content marketing, lead nurturing, and customer relationship management (CRM) strategies. For example, an educational platform can repurpose blog content into email newsletters to drive traffic to its website and increase course sign-ups.
Social media complements influencer partnerships, community building, and cross-platform promotions, such as a fashion retailer collaborating with influencers on Instagram to showcase new collections and expand its audience reach.
8. How important is message longevity for you?
Email marketing messages have a longer lifespan as they reside in recipients’ inboxes until actioned. In contrast, social media content has a shorter lifespan influenced by platform algorithms and user engagement.
For instance, if you are a financial services firm that wants to send quarterly investment tips and updates to your customers, you should go for email.
But if you are a food delivery service with limited-time offers, message longevity is not important for you. You should focus on adapting your Facebook content strategy in response to algorithm updates to ensure posts reach a wider audience.
Let's see how the two marketing channels perform in terms of message longevity.
| Factors to consider | Email marketing | Social media marketing |
|---|---|---|
| Message lifespan | Messages can be saved and revisited by recipients | Posts have a shorter lifespan due to feed updates |
| Visibility challenges | Less impacted by platform algorithm changes | Algorithm updates may affect post visibility |
| Content evergreenness | Well-suited for evergreen content and detailed information | Emphasizes current and trending content |
| Audience reach over time | Maintains reach over longer periods | Requires consistent posting to maintain visibility |
| Adaptability to changes | Less affected by platform policy changes | Requires adaptation to new social media features |
Create campaign ideas with
AI Email Campaign Planner
Email marketing vs social media marketing: final verdict
Both email marketing and social media marketing have unique advantages. The questions mentioned above will help you understand your needs and settle the debate about email marketing vs social media marketing.
You should make the decision based on your business goals, audience preferences, budget, and content strategy. You can integrate both strategies to enhance your overall marketing impact by leveraging each channel's strengths to effectively connect with your target audience.
If you choose email marketing and aim to enhance engagement, start leveraging interactive emails. Mailmodo helps create interactive email experiences that drive higher interaction rates and customer engagement.
Book a demo with Mailmodo today to boost your email engagement rate with interactive emails!
